Jimmy Neesham accuses India of ‘blatantly doctoring’ wickets at home following pitch debate after 78 all out
New Zealand all-rounder Jimmy Neesham nearly accused India of pitch doctoring as, amid England’s excellent bowling and visitors’ disastrous 78 all out on Day 1 of the Headingley Test, the discussion somehow shifted to the track on offer in Leeds.
While there wasn’t anything prodigious swing or seam movement on offer for the English seamers, they still managed to create uncertainty outside off-stump and induced multiple errors that led to the Indian batsmen’s downfall.
Managing to sneak through to lunch at 58/4, India added only another 20 runs to their total after the break at the loss of their last six wickets.
At this point in time, while one half of the cricketing world raved over England’s class bowling, the other criticised India’s batting unit for their disappointing show.
Also Read: ‘Which Generation, What Exactly Is Bullying?’ – Sunil Gavaskar Slams Sony Guest Hussain On Air
Jimmy Neesham throws up contentious claim regarding Indian tracks
Amidst all that, renowned journalist Tim Wigmore wondered if the surface would have been in focus a lot more had this collapse was in India and England were at the receiving end of some unrelenting bowling? As was the case when Axar Patel and Ravichandran Ashwin feasted against English batsmen in the final three Tests of the series in February-March.
Not taking away from England, who were absolutely outstanding. But Ahmedabad v Headingley Tests this year do show the odd double standards in how we view spinning v seaming pitches
— Tim Wigmore (@timwig) August 25, 2021
This is where Neesham started conversing and argued, as those from abroad have tended to, that the only ideal surface for Test match cricket is the one that turns on the final couple of days and not from the very beginning.
“Is this not obvious? A pitch that seams on day 1/2 then is good for batting days 3/4 then good for spin on days 4/5 is perfect. Everyone is in the game at different points. If it spins on day 1 it’s just a spinner’s paradise for 5 days. That’s shit,” Jimmy Neesham tweeted.
Is this not obvious? A pitch that seams on day 1/2 then is good for batting days 3/4 then good for spin on days 4/5 is perfect. Everyone is in the game at different points. If it spins on day 1 it’s just a spinner’s paradise for 5 days. That’s shit.
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
And even asked if he wants no variety in Test match surfaces across the world, Neesham responded: “Variety is fine and the different conditions in each country will always provide differing surfaces. It will always swing and seam in England and always spin in India.”
“It gets a bit suss when home teams just blatantly doctor their own wickets to a ridiculous level,” he added in a controversial implication that India “doctor” their surfaces for their spinners to flourish and take bagful of wickets.
Variety is fine and the different conditions in each country will always provide differing surfaces. It will always swing and seam in England and always spin in India. It gets a bit suss when home teams just blatantly doctor their own wickets to a ridiculous level.
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
Following this, Jimmy Neesham started receiving quite a few counter-arguments from fans over Twitter. But the cricketer remained firm over his stance.
I would say a pitch has been doctored when the surface you get for a Test match is outlandishly different from what that surface would normally be for a domestic game. https://t.co/monmSqet2d
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
Let me get this straight… are you saying that a pitch where NZ got 432/6 declared was too bowler friendly? https://t.co/rSlZFHWLdz
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
Is that the game where both teams scored 500? https://t.co/WBFaYahD5Q
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
Yes, your logic is absolutely correct, well done. A pitch that is just flat on day 5 is also a shit pitch https://t.co/QkGQEOTO5A
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
How about in indore? Got 70 before a shocking lbw decision https://t.co/sq2NpiHp3t
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
Twitter isn’t real, don’t get so worked up over nothing
Enjoy the Test, I’m off for a pint
— Jimmy Neesham (@JimmyNeesh) August 25, 2021
This is, of course, not the first time that Neesham has found himself in the midst of a controversial debate following a statement over social media. The cricketer has previously also had multiple instances when he has had to face the wrath of passionate fans over an opinion.