Categories: Post-matchAnalysis

How the DRS baffled the third umpire, Sri Lankans and Suryakumar Yadav in bizarre review during Sri Lanka-India ODI


Bizarre scenes were on display at the start of the 23rd over in the Indian innings before rain brought the proceedings to a halt in the third and final ODI against Sri Lanka in Colombo this Friday (July 22).

Indian batsman Suryakumar Yadav was given out on LBW by on-field umpire Kumar Dharmasena when a delivery from left-arm spinner Praveen Jayawickrama seemed to have struck him plumb infront.

After discussing the matter with his batting partner Manish Pandey, Suryakumar opted for a DRS review where the ball-tracking technology predicted the delivery to be hitting the stumps but the impact was just outside the off-stump with the distance between the point of impact and the stumps being 2.5 metres.

It would’ve been a straightforward call to give Suryakumar Yadav not out but third umpire Raveendra Wimalasiri ended up creating confusion on the field as he delayed his decision-making and continued to check the path of the ball despite the impact being clearly outside off.

A Suryakumar Yadav LBW review which left everyone puzzled

How the third umpire fueled confusion around the Suryakumar Yadav LBW call?

As Wimalasiri kept checking the track of the delivery, it raised the hopes of the Sri Lankan team keenly looking at the giant screen. They even jumped up to celebrate when they saw the ball hitting the stumps on the predicted path. Forgetting in their excitement, however, that it can’t be out as per the LBW laws if the ball has struck the batsman outside off stump.

Once he saw the Lankans celebrate, Suryakumar started walking back to the pavilion, before he was thankfully called back by the two on-field umpires, including Dharamsena, to resume his innings.

The bizarre incident also brought to light the 2.5 metres clause in the existing DRS arrangement. The rule first came under the spotlight when during the India-England 2011 World Cup game in Bangalore, visiting batsman Ian Bell was saved by this clause despite the LBW review showing ominous signs for him.

Bell was struck in line with the middle stump off a delivery facing Yuvraj Singh but umpire Billy Bowden turned down the Indians’ appeal, which forced captain MS Dhoni to opt for the review. Once the replay was unveiled on the screen, Bell started walking off, presuming he is about to be declared out. But Bowden’s on-field call was ultimately persisted with once the ball-tracking showed the distance between the point of impact and the stumps to be 2.5 metres.

The call only added to India’s displeasure about the DRS at the time. Dhoni was vocal in his criticism of the decision that the technology arrived at. But the then ICC CEO Haroon Lorgat said the 2.5-metre clause was added to the DRS only to avoid the howlers as the ball-tracking technology isn’t self-admitted 100% correct in asserting the predicted path.

In a simple definition, the clause says if the ball needs to travel to the stumps by a distance of 2.5 metres or more, the ball tracking doesn’t yet give a clear path of the ball. On such occasions, it makes sense to go by the on-field umpire’s understanding and expertise around an LBW decision.

Kashish Chadha

A cricket writer by heart and profession. Currently at work for CricXtasy. Previously with Circle of Cricket. You can find him on Twitter @crickashish217

Comments are closed.

Recent Posts

T20 World Cup 2021: Temba Bavuma all praise for South Africa bowlers after win against West Indies

South Africa captain Temba Bavuma praised his bowlers’ class after an eight-wicket win over the West Indies got their Super…

14 hours ago

T20 World Cup 2021: Why Afghanistan’s huge win against Scotland should worry India

Afghanistan's resounding victory over Scotland in Sharjah on Monday (October 25) could prove to be a dent to India's chances…

14 hours ago

WATCH: Umpire Aleem Dar ducks to avoid being hit by Pollard’s shot, nearly gets hit by throw from other side

Senior umpire Aleem Dar was at the center of a hilarious incident during the ICC Men's T20 World Cup game…

19 hours ago

Quinton de Kock opts out of SA vs WI game; Twitter wonders if it’s due to CSA’s BLM stance? 

South Africa's former skipper and experienced opening batter Quinton de Kock on Tuesday (October 26) opted out of his team's…

22 hours ago

ENG vs BAN Dream11 Prediction for T20 World Cup 2021: Playing XI, Fantasy Cricket Tips, Team, Weather Updates and Pitch Report

Preview for ENG vs BAN Dream11 Contest: After dominating West Indies in their opening game, England will be hoping to…

22 hours ago

HB-W vs MS-W Dream11 Prediction for WBBL 2021-22: Playing XI, Fantasy Cricket Tips, Team, Weather Updates and Pitch Report

Preview for HB-W vs MS-W Dream11 Contest: Hobart Hurricanes will be taking on the Melbourne Stars in Match 20th of…

23 hours ago